Moving Tips
How to Read Reviews and Choose the Right Moving Company
Reviews are one of the best tools you have for picking a mover, as long as you read them the right way. Here is how to get the real story behind the stars.
Moving Tips · October 20, 2026 · 5 min read
Start With Research, Not Just Ratings
Most people begin their search for movers on Google or Yelp, and that is a fine starting point. Just do not sort by stars and call the first result. A rating on its own can mislead. One company may have a handful of short, generic five-star posts, while another sits slightly lower but has hundreds of detailed reviews from real customers.
Look across several sites, such as Google, Yelp, Angi, and the Better Business Bureau. Comparing platforms reveals patterns, and a slightly lower score backed by specific, believable reviews often points to the more dependable company.
Read the Reviews, Don't Just Glance at Them
Skimming will not tell you much. Pick several reviews and read them start to finish, then look for themes. Do customers keep praising how carefully fragile items were wrapped? Do multiple people mention late crews or unexpected charges?
Recurring themes say far more than any single rave or rant. Specific reviews are more useful than vague praise, and reading closely shows you how the company really operates day to day.
Watch Out for Fake or Filtered Reviews
Not every review is written by a real customer, and fakes can be glowing or scathing. Watch for one-line posts like "Great job!" with no details, and for a burst of perfect reviews all published on the same day.
Be cautious with platforms that hide reviews or only display a curated selection, and with sites that do not let businesses reply. A trustworthy mover accepts feedback of every kind. Companies that answer calmly and professionally, especially when something went wrong, tend to be the ones worth hiring.
Look for Details That Match Your Situation
Movers have different strengths. One company may excel at long-distance moves but be less suited to a small studio. Another may be the reverse.
Read with your own move in mind. Moving into a fifth-floor walk-up in Manhattan? Find reviews from people who dealt with the same stairs. Relocating a large house to another state? Focus on reviews describing that kind of job. The reviews that look most like your move are the most valuable.
Pay Attention to Customer Service Mentions
How a mover treats people says a lot. Mistakes happen on any job; what counts is the response. A review that mentions a scratched dresser but also says the company made it right quickly is actually a good sign.
Notice whether the company replies to reviews online. A respectful, constructive reply to a complaint tells you more about how you will be treated than a flawless score does.
Check How the Company Handles Quotes and Pricing
Money is where most moving complaints start. Reviewers often say whether the final bill matched the estimate, so look for that detail. Hidden fees and confusing pricing are among the most frequent grievances.
Strong reviews mention honesty. Were rates explained clearly? Were extras like stairs, wait time, or long carries discussed up front? Movers who set expectations early avoid surprises later. At MPs New York we give written quotes and offer flat-rate pricing so the number you see is the number you plan around.
Don't Just Rely on Reviews: Verify Credentials
Good reviews matter, but so do licensing and insurance. For an interstate move, look up the company's USDOT number. For a local move, confirm licensing with the state transportation department.
The FMCSA website lets you check that a carrier's registration and insurance are active. Reviews tell you what happened to other people; credentials and valuation coverage protect you if something goes wrong on your move. Do not skip this step.
Ask Questions Before You Book
Once you have a short list, call or email each company. A reliable mover explains things clearly, answers patiently, and does not pressure you. Their answers to these questions say a lot:
Questions worth asking
- How long have you been moving customers in this area?
- Do you use your own crews and trucks, or subcontract the move?
- What happens if something is lost or damaged?
- Which charges could change the final price?
- Do you provide a written estimate and a bill of lading?
Compare More Than Just Reviews
Reviews are one input among several. Weigh experience, services, and pricing too. A company with fewer reviews can still be the stronger choice if it has a long, steady track record. A cheap mover with lots of reviews might be cutting corners somewhere else.
Put it all together, from reviews and credentials to pricing and experience, and each piece adds confidence to your decision. Do you need packing, storage, or help with a piano? Make sure the company you choose actually does that work well.
Make an Informed, Confident Decision
Choosing a mover comes down to trust. You are inviting people into your home and handing them everything you own, so the choice matters.
Reviews are a great guide when you use them carefully. Take your time, read closely, look for patterns, and balance what you read against credentials and experience. Listen to your instincts as well. A little extra effort now can spare you stress, hidden costs, and regret on moving day.
See how we work before you book
Request a written quote from MPs New York and ask us anything. Clear answers are part of the service.